Current Meeting Home Final Program Past & Future Meetings

Back to 2015 Annual Meeting Posters


Resident and Faculty Perceptions of the Value of End-of-Rotation Oral Examinations
*Ryland S Stucke, Kari M Rosenkranz, Paul H Kispert
Dartmouth, Lebanon, NH

OBJECTIVE: Determine the value of end-of rotation oral examinations.
DESIGN: Survey
SETTING: Academic residency program
PARTICIPANTS:
PGY 3 - 5 (N=8) Faculty (N=10)
INTERVENTIONS: None
MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Perception of oral exams to test knowledge and prepare residents for board examinations.
RESULTS:
FACULTY PERCEPTIONS
Expectation of resident performanceMet 70%Did not meet 30%
Resident’s knowledgeAt/above expected 70%Below
Expected 30%
My ability to assess resident knowledge prior to mock oralGood 100%Poor 0%
Mock oral exams vs. ABSITE as a test of knowledgeBetter 50%Similar 30%Different 20%
Didactics/clinical conferences adequately assess resident knowledgeYes 50%No 50%
Oral exam helpful in assessing knowledgeYes 90%No 10%

RESIDENT PERCEPTIONS
Difficulty of Oral ExamExpected 75%Harder 12%Easier 12%
Assessment of KnowledgeExpected 62%Worse than expected 38%
Exam identified my knowledge gapsMany 25%Few 75%None 0
Surprised by my knowledge gapsNot surprised 38%Mildly surprised 63%Very surprised 0
Mock oral vs ABSITE to test knowledgeBetter 75%Similar 12%Worse 12%

Resident results: Preparation for QE/CE
YESNO
Didactic system (SCORE) prepares for QE / CE25%75%
Clinical conferences prepare for QE / CE12%88%
Frequent oral exams helpful in passing CE / QE88%12%

CONCLUSIONS
Faculty members feel that clinical interactions predict performance on oral examinations. The oral format detected unexpected knowledge deficits. Residents feel frequent oral examinations provide a better test of knowledge than the ABSITE and better preparation for the CE / QE than the SCORE curriculum or clinical conferences. Faculty and residents feel strongly that frequent mock oral exams are beneficial. Oral examinations should be incorporated into the resident curriculum.


Back to 2015 Annual Meeting Posters


© 2021 New England Surgical Society. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy.